Hi, I'm Brian Natale.
As your local insurance agent of 13 years in Ontario, NY, I help customers like you identify the insurance coverage that best fits your needs. This straightforward, personalized process helps you become smarter about insurance. I have the knowledge and experience to help you better understand your coverage options — whether that's auto, home, renters, business insurance, life insurance, and more.
To be the customers' natural first choice in all the products we sell and be recognized as an indispensable partner in a family's well-balanced financial portfolio. We are located on Route 104 in Ontario, NY.
"We offer more because we ARE more!"

Our Vision
Our Motto
My Biography
My insurance journey began in 2014 after a 23-year career in corporate finance, serving in senior leadership positions, including multiple Corporate CFO roles, with organizations generating $400 million to $1.2 billion in annual revenue. My expertise focused on financial restructuring, operational improvement, and restoring profitability.
Seeking a new entrepreneurial challenge and greater time with my family, I transitioned into the insurance industry in 2014, applying my financial and accounting expertise to building a successful business. I hold a Bachelor of Science in Accounting from Le Moyne College and an MBA in Corporate Accounting and Finance from the Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT).
I find great satisfaction in helping families navigate their unique insurance needs and protect their financial futures. At Brian Natale Agency LLC., our vision is to “Be our customers’ natural first choice in all the products we offer and be recognized as an indispensable partner in maintaining a well-balanced family financial portfolio.” This commitment guides our approach to every client relationship. I take pride in providing each family with the care, attention, and protection I would expect for my own.
I live in Webster, New York and value the strong community ties of the greater Rochester area. Outside of work, I enjoy family time, golfing, hiking, downhill skiing, and automobiles, particularly detailing and maintaining exceptional finishes. These interests reflect my appreciation for precision, craftsmanship, and attention to detail—qualities I bring to my professional responsibilities every day.
Meet Our Team
Here at the Brian Natale Agency, LLC, we are a collective of industry experts dedicated
to providing you with the most secure and comprehensive protection solutions available.


